I think this is a cute idea with potential, and I know from the description that you will still make improvements, so I will only comment on the improvements I think are more crucial for the gameplay. The adding ingredients to the mixing table is a bit fail-prone, it's easy to put then on the table but not inside the minigame, and it feels like that could easily be fixed with adjustments to the collision areas. For the mixing, I was confused because I didn't realize I had to click the ingredients after I had supposedly added them already. It would be nice to have a progress bar to know if I'm doing the right thing or not. In the oven stage, I didn't understand the purpose of closing the door, or if it was needed, and why the progress bar gets hidden when I close the door. I burned 3 cakes, until I realized the purpose was not to get the green bar to be full. I think those were the main parts that affected my experience. I'm curious to see how part 2 will look!

Great work! The cake making steps are so funsies and I 100% boogied around the kitchen to the soundtrack lol. Cant' wait to play the finished piece!!